Book Review – Drawing Down the Moon (Part 2)

The second section of Drawing Down the Moon concerns Wicca and is by far the largest section of the book.  This is, perhaps, fitting given the author’s involvement with Wicca and given Wicca’s predominant position within neo-Paganism.  However, as the audience of this review is expected to be Druids, I will not dwell long on the this part of the book here except to say that it is a refreshingly honest report by Adler upon her own path.  It manages at once to dispel romantic notions that modern Wiccans are carrying on a tradition kept secret but unbroken since the Inquisition, while at the same time validating Wicca as a modern spiritual and magical path.  This is a lesson which should not be lost on ADF dedicants!

Greek vase image depicting the Drawing Down the Moon ritual from the inside cover of the book

I should note that within this second section, the most relevant chapter to ADF members is likely that on Magic and Ritual.  I will perhaps return to and explore this chapter more in a future blog posting.

The third section of the book concerns all of the other Pagans.  In 70 less pages than she spent on Wiccans, Adler takes us through a whirl-wind tour of every other significant path; Hesperian, Sabaean, Kemetic, Asatru, and Radical Faeries amongst others.

After the deep plunge into Wicca, this section disappoints for several reasons.

The first and foremost reason is that Adler focuses on the history and major players within the paths rather than what it means to walk the path.  As an example, in the ten pages she devotes to the Kemetic path, Adler writes almost exclusively about the history and founders of the Church of the Eternal Source and says next to nothing about what it means to be a member.  What do they believe?  What are their rituals like?  The book says next to nothing.

The second reason this section disappoints is that Adler dwells at length on paths that may have been  interesting and potentially had an impact on modern neo-Paganism but which are considered really very ‘fringe’ these days.  The most obvious example here is the entire chapter spent on the Church of All Worlds which by the 2006 revision of Drawing Down the Moon was clearly no longer considered a valid spiritual path by most Pagans.

Still, even the pages spent on groups like the Church of All Worlds would not be so disappointing if, in context, the ‘living’ paths were given at least equal treatment.  Unfortunately, this is not to be.  Asatru likely makes out the best with perhaps 14 pages, but Druidry – despite getting second mention in the books sub-title “Witches, Druids, Goddess-Worshippers, and other Pagans in America” – has only about ten pages.  Even worse, it is included in the chapter titled “Religions of Paradox and Play”.  While such a chapter is an appropriate place to discuss the Reformed Druids of North America, it relegates the much more serious efforts of Ár nDraíocht Féin into the same bucket.  Of course, given that only given two out of the ten pages on Druidry is devoted to ADF, this is perhaps understandable if not entirely forgivable.

Continue to Part Three

2 thoughts on “Book Review – Drawing Down the Moon (Part 2)

  1. I’m not sure that I would consider The Church of All Worlds, “fringe” or claim that it is “no longer considered a a valid spiritual path by most Pagans.” Who are you to say what is valid and what is not? CAW has had an immense influence on Modern Paganism, and continues to have an influence. Nearly anyone over 35 involved in Paganism today has been influenced by CAW in some way shape or form, and before the internet “Green Egg” was America’s most popular Pagan forum. Oberon Zell, one of the founders of CAW, remains a popular presence on the Pagan lecture circuit, and Oberon’s “Mythic Images” line of Pagan statuary remains very popular.

    While CAW always had a relatively small membership (kind of like ADF) it wielded (and still wields) tremendous influence (kind of like ADF). The word “Pagan” as an umbrella term for Witches, Druids, Wiccans, Heathens, etc., was popularized by, you guessed it, Oberon Zell of CAW!

    • Hi there. Thanks for dropping by and commenting!

      My point about CAW is not that they weren’t exceptionally influential for modern Paganism. My point was that if Drawing Down the Moon is meant to be a contemporary overview of current paths (as suggested in the word “today” within it’s sub-title) it is failing to do so; its failure is due in large part to spending a disproportionately large amount of ink on paths that no longer attract significant numbers of new followers rather than paths such as Asatru which are growing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s